Brent council in north-west London helped push the UK government to scrap the ‘aim to permit’ principle from the Gambling Act this month, citing a ‘gambling harms emergency’ on its high streets. Yet licensing data reviewed by iGB shows the borough has not granted a single betting shop licence in 13 years. The gap between the political campaign and the numbers underneath it raises a harder question about what the reform is actually meant to fix.
Brent ranks second in London for gambling premises, a concentration that gave local politicians the platform to lobby Downing Street. But the borough’s own database tells a quieter story: total premises fell from 83 in January 2025 to 75 now, a net loss of eight in under two years.
What Brent’s Numbers Reveal About the Reform
The Brent case matters because it was used as evidence for a national policy shift. Strip away the rhetoric and the data points in the opposite direction to the campaign that produced it. Here is what the story means for operators, councils and regulators watching the fallout.
- The evidentiary basis is thin. Brent last approved a betting shop in 2013, and only three Adult Gaming Centres opened in the borough over five years, undercutting the premise of runaway proliferation.
- Retail gambling is already contracting nationally, which weakens the case for new restrictions.
- Legal uncertainty is now the main risk. The government has not confirmed whether it is amending Section 153, Section 22, or both, leaving operators and councils without a clear framework to plan around.
- A parallel evidence-based mechanism, Gambling Impact Assessments, was already arriving, making the removal of aim to permit look redundant.
- Incumbent operators with acquisition-led strategies may benefit as new-store approvals get harder.
A National Decline, Reframed as a Crisis
Prime Minister Andy Burnham announced the change by framing betting shops among ‘dodgy businesses’ crowding the high street. The Gambling Commission’s own figures complicate that framing. Betting shop numbers have fallen from a peak of 9,128 in 2012 to 5,789 in 2025. Betfred and Evoke have both signalled plans to shutter hundreds more.
AGCs have followed a similar curve, dropping from 2,247 in 2012 to 1,464 in 2019, then flattening to 1,415 this year. So the sector politicians describe as spreading has, on paper, been shrinking for over a decade.
Greg Knight, CEO and owner of independent bookmaker JenningsBet, told iGB his brand opened just four shops nationally last year. His read on the politics is blunt. “What’s Andy Burnham gonna do next, promise to shut down all the video shops?”
Politics Over Policy
Analyst Scott Longley, writing in his Earnings+More newsletter, noted that operators are absorbing a “markedly harsher political backdrop.” What troubles compliance specialists is that the backdrop, and the policy it produced, does not appear tethered to evidence.
Aim to permit is a load-bearing part of the Gambling Act’s balance between personal liberty and harm prevention. Removing it reads more like a political win than a considered reform. Dawn Butler, the Brent MP who campaigned hardest for the change, declared victory in a Guardian opinion piece. She did not set out what replaces the principle she helped delete.
Luisa Clark, a UK compliance specialist and founder of RulePlay, cautions against reading too much into the headline. “I think there’s a lot of oversimplification of what this actually means in practice,” she said. “Removing those three words is the beginning of the exercise. What’s much more important is what replaces them. What is going to underpin the decisions?”
And then the sharper point: “Evidence is a massive issue as well. It’s already an issue now, it’s going to become an even bigger issue.”
The Redundancy Nobody Explained
Gambling Impact Assessments sharpen the puzzle. Passed through a devolution bill in April, GIAs are statutory powers letting councils refuse new premises where evidence shows a licence would undermine their licensing objectives. They are due to take effect soon.
That is precisely the evidence-based lever a borough like Brent could have pulled. Which raises the obvious question: why overturn aim to permit when a mechanism achieving the same end was already in the post?
Knight, whose growth comes through acquisition rather than new sites, expects little direct impact and even sees an incumbent’s advantage in tighter approvals. Still, he shares the confusion. “The risk assessments were there, it was in the post anyway,” he said.
Andrew Lyman, Gibraltar’s Gambling Commissioner and a former UK Gambling Commission director, went further on the stakes. “If the policy announcement was superficial then that could be seen as irresponsible. Government really needs to take care that gambling policy does not take us back to before 1961 where demand for betting (and now gaming machine use) is met by the illegal market as opposed to regulated operators.”
Clark also questions the premise itself. “The Gambling Act is specifically about gambling risk, it’s about gambling premises and gambling risk. It can’t really do much to change the face of the high street, but they’re using aim to permit as kind of the vehicle to do that.”
An Image Problem the Sector Helped Build
Reputation shadows every decision here, from the Prime Minister’s word choice down to a Somerset council refusing an AGC last week on grounds it would degrade the town centre. One councillor said: “I don’t gamble, but I don’t understand why it is a good thing,” before adding, “Whatever the regulations say, we know [gambling] is an issue.”
Not everyone in the industry sees the backlash as unfair. Alun Bowden, SVP strategic insights at Eilers & Krejcik Gaming, wrote on LinkedIn that the sector “often refuses to consider how lots of other people view it.” His closing line landed harder than most industry defences: “If you can’t see where you are the problem, how can you ever find the solution?”
Terry White, a former betting shop manager turned gambling harms advocate, pins the policy mood on conduct. He argues the sector lost a culture of staff intervening when players got into trouble. “There’s always a place in any high street for a well-run betting shop. What I always object to is when they come along, they stick staff in with very little training, little interest, low pay, and all of a sudden it’s like walking into the Wild West.”
Shrinking Footprint, Rising Revenue
The retail picture is not one of collapse but of consolidation. Knight calls the closures a “right-sizing rather than a death knell.” The revenue data supports him.
| Metric | Change since 2019 |
|---|---|
| Betting GGR per shop | Up 37% |
| Betting shop numbers | Down 24% |
| AGC premises | Broadly flat (1,464 in 2019 to 1,415 in 2025) |
Fewer shops, each earning more. That is a market normalising, not one being overrun.
Why the Political Risk Outweighs the Economic One
The Betting and Gaming Council frames the sector’s contribution in economic terms and presses for research-backed policy. “The industry will continue making the case for evidence-led, proportionate policy and demonstrating the contribution it makes to jobs, investment and high streets,” the group told iGB. “What matters is that Government fully considers the cumulative impact of further tax and regulatory change.”
That cumulative impact is stacking up: affordability checks, the mandatory industry levy, an online tax hike, aim to permit removal, and a possible increase to machine game duty. Knight, even so, is confident retail demand holds. His worry sits elsewhere entirely.
“My actual concern is not the economics, I think there’s enough demand there,” he said. “My big concern is political.”
Frequently Asked Questions
What is ‘aim to permit’ and why does it matter?
It is a principle in the Gambling Act instructing licensing authorities to grant gambling premise applications unless there is good reason not to. It underpins the Act’s balance between treating gambling as a legitimate leisure activity and controlling its harms. Removing it shifts the default position councils start from.
Which part of the Gambling Act is being changed?
The government has not confirmed. Industry has assumed the target is Section 153, which guides council-level decisions, but Section 22 also places an aim to permit duty on the Gambling Commission itself. If Section 22 is amended, the reach could extend to operator licensing and regulation more broadly.
What are Gambling Impact Assessments?
Statutory powers passed through a devolution bill in April 2025, letting councils refuse new premises where evidence shows harm to their licensing objectives. They offered an evidence-based route to the same outcome aim to permit removal is meant to deliver.
Are betting shops actually increasing in number?
No. National figures show a fall from 9,128 shops in 2012 to 5,789 in 2025, with further closures announced by major operators.
Does the reform threaten the retail sector’s survival?
Operators frame current closures as consolidation rather than decline, pointing to a 37% rise in revenue per shop since 2019. The greater concern voiced across the industry is political direction, not demand.
